Phillies Sign Manuel to a 2-Year Deal

The Phillies inked manager Charlie Manuel to a two year deal with a club option for 2010. The not been the biggest Manuel fan, but in some ways I dont mind it and in other ways I think...they can do better cant they?

Why I like it:

1. Maybe the most important reason...the players like him. Its tough to play for a guy you dont like and dont respect. The players like and respect Charlie, so I like that.

2. While in the locker room after game 1 and game 2 of the playoffs, I never really sensed any panic around this team and i was impressed by that. That comes from the manager.

3. His mistakes in-games, still make for good radio.

Why I dont like it:

1. His in-game managing still needs a lot of work. He makes way to many mistakes that end up hurting his team.

2. There are going to be better options on the market this offseason and maybe thats what this team needs to get over the hump to go from a good team to great team.

3. Maybe the Phillies brought him back and set him up to fail. Its easier to blame Charlie then it is yourself for not getting the right guys this offseason. An offseason that is barron of top level talent on the free agent market. Remember Charlie has never been the most popular guy in the Philadelphia region and the Phillies management has to know that.

4. What if the Phillies get off to another 4-11 type of start b/c Charlie doesnt have them prepared and ready. It has happened all 3 years with him here and if it happens again, will they again be able to hope the Mets have a historic colapasse to get them into the playoffs again.

5. If injuries occur again, will Charlie be able to remain calm knowing he is on a 2-year deal, rather then the lame duck status he had this season. He had his hands tied and he knew it, so he no choice but to keep his mouth shut....will he be as patient with some leverage?

Overall, the Phillies wouldn't go after Torre, LaRussa, Girardi or any other top level manager that might be available. So, he might be the next best thing. His record does speak volumes of the kind of guy he must be, beacuse he still is very poor at managing a game.

Thoughts ?
e-mail me - themikegillshow@gmail.com

Talk to you on the radio.....